Dear Flutists,
Over the weekend there was a discussion on Galway's chatgroup about Longtones, working on Tone, and what the deal is with all that. One adult flute student wrote:
"When I was in my teens, my flute teacher had me work on LONGTONES, and they were horribly boring to me. All I did was hold each note 'for as long as possible' and my tone never improved. Even today, having taken the flute back up again, I wish for a fabulous tone, and when I play longtones, nothing changes; my tone still sounds like an amateur. How does one fix this?"
Jen replies:
(
longtones demonstrated along with posture at video here.)
The core of the "longtones" misunderstanding may in fact be the same problem that led Trevor Wye to write "
Tone - vol. 1" from his
Practise Books for the Flute series.
Wye said on (one of the flute email groups) that originally, he developed the idea of writing "Tone Vol. 1" after he had listened to fellow flute students warming up for a masterclass in Europe,
To his shock he heard several quite advanced flute students playing "LONGtones" for 30 minutes at a time, but they were longtones that had horrible tone quality, and no musicality. The students sounded bored, earnest, and horrible.
Wye thought they'd missed the entire point of Moyse's advice in "Sonorite" which is to only play with a gorgeous tone, and slowly move it from one note to the next as you proceed with the exercise.
So, let's start with that:
The very purpose of longtones is to hold a *beautiful* tone for a few seconds, and to build up your memory of how to always produce a *beautiful* tone. The memory will be partially through your "mouth-to-ear" co-ordination, and partially a physical, muscular memory of what steps you took to find that marvellous tone again.
Just to be clear;
the wrong way to perform Moyse's "Sonorite" would be:
- to play a long horrible sounding tone
- to play unmusically and boringly
- to try and hold the note "as long as possible no matter what"
- to play with a strained face, strained, tight lips, or closed throat
- to play with the lungs almost empty of air
- to hold the air back and try and play with a small sound
- to train yourself to do all of the above at the same time while boring yourself and not improving, but getting worse tone. :>)
So in the "Vol 1 - Tone" book by Wye, he tries to explain that first you find a beautiful tone on a simple and easy note, playing from mezzo forte, and crescendo-ing, and then you deliberately spread that tone to the surrounding notes. You do this by locating the greatest sound quality you can make (on any given day--some days are greater than others...;>))and then lovingly descending a semitone to see if that great sound quality can be had for free in the neighbouring notes that surround your best tone note.
That's it.
Eleanor Lawrence alludes to this too in her DVD (which some were recommending this weekend), but not in any great detail, I find (I have the DVD).
Lawrence assumes (as do those who've been taught that 'great tone' is the goal of the
first note of the exercise) that the flute student understands this TONE-SONORITE concept already: That you first achieve one beautiful tone pitch, and then start moving through other notes on the flute.
On the other hand, for those flutists and teachers who have just somehow missed this point, it's all about getting the tone to sound
best before holding the note. It is far easier to begin this work in the lower registers, and then, after a month or two, to begin to spread this tone to the higher register (embouchure development favours the high registers
after the low registers are already reliably beautiful.)
To learn this concept of Sonorite you can:
a) match your teacher's tone during longtones in lessons
b) get your teacher's one-on-one advice about changes you might try in your breathing, posture, holding the flute etc.
c) get your teacher's advice (individualized) on letting the air move freely through your chest, throat, mouth and body
d) get your teacher's advice on changes you could experiment with your lips/embouchure/mouth position.
Quite a few of these possible suggestions are listed on my
tone help pages on my website. But of course, you can't learn the sound you need to hear from a book, only from a great tone that is being demonstrated to you by a live player.
And yes, it all starts with:
If your single tone on one note sounds the best it can sound, you're creating a physical memory of how to continue to play with great tone.
Hard to explain in words, of course, but instantly understood in a good flute lesson with a teacher showing a bad tone, and a good tone, and then holding the
good tone only, while proceding with the Sonorite exercises by Moyse, spreading the good sound from note to note.
It's important to know , for advanced students that the 30+ page book called "Tone Vol. 1" by Trevor Wye, examines in detail only the
first semitone exercise from Moyse's "De La Sonorite".
Although somewhat expensive, owning the whole Moyse Sonorite book is a good investment as it has additional, more advanced exercises in dynamics, leaping large intervals, and phrasing.
Advanced flute students who've completed the Moyse book may also enjoy working with these books;
Check Up by Peter Lukas Graf and/or
Tone Development Through Interpretation by Moyse and/or
Conditioning Training by Werner Richter and/or
Tone Development Through Extended Technique by Robert Dick and there is a nice, slim book of inspriational suggestions called
Playing in Colours by Ann Cherry.
On my fourth coffee on a saturday morning,
Jen :>)